Concordia, a holding controlled by the Rothschild family, is planning to take the eponymous French bank private in a deal that values it about 3.7 billion.
What’s the point of being listed? Even the bankers are wondering. Rothschild & Co.’s controlling family wants to take it private, arguing investors don’t appreciate the storied boutique bank’s long-term potential. It’s the latest case of private buyers exploiting stock-market indifference.
February 07, 2023 / 05:08 PM IST
In the US, the trend for financial firms has been in the other direction: Entrepreneurial advisory shops specialising in mergers and acquisitions have been lining up to go public since Goldman Sachs Group Inc. became the last major Wall Street firm to take a listing in 1999. Perella Weinberg Partners’s merger with a blank-check firm reinforced the trend.
The attractions of going public are clear enough for such boutiques. Selling a stake enables founders to cash in and creates equity that can be used to reward staff. An initial public offering is the default route simply because a sale to another financial firm is hard to engineer. The bulge-bracket firms don’t need to buy you; and private equity funds are going to drive a hard bargain.
But things are more complicated over at Rothschild. For all its history, Rothschild is another mid-cap European stock that’s thinly traded and suffers limited analyst coverage.
Concordia — the Rothschild family’s holding company and the dominant shareholder — says the bank doesn’t need access to the equity market for capital, and suggests the business is being assessed by investors only on “short-term earnings.” The family has been looking to increase ownership, not shed it.
You can see the frustration with the market. Rothschild has performed well operationally, but you wouldn’t think so from the share price. The stock was trading at 7.5 times next-12-month earnings prior to the take-private bid emerging on Monday. US peers trade on 16 times. Rothschild trades on a 10 percent premium to book value, again below the US sector.
Stuck in the Middle | Rothschild’s humdrum share-price performance has tested owners’ patience
The market capitalisation was only 3 billion euros ($3.2 billion) at Friday’s close; the free-float of tradeable shares is less than half the total. US investors have bigger, more liquid ways of investing in the industry, and without also being in a disadvantaged minority.
Of course, one remedy would be a merger with another boutique bringing more scale and diversification. Such a deal, however, could also dilute the Rothschild family’s influential position and create a more conventional share register. That’s the snag: The loss of family control is precisely why bulking up through a merger isn’t an option.
For Rothschild the business, going private wouldn’t be an unambiguously good move. Regulation means it must pay senior staff partly in stock. There’ll be a need to replicate those programs with some kind of phantom equity rewards, which are harder to value than conventional share-based remuneration.
But the main hurdle to the Concordia plan going through will be the minority shareholders. The offer came when Rothschild stock and the Paris CAC-40 index weren’t far off all-time highs. It scarcely looks opportunistic against that backdrop. Moreover, the family already has control, which is a philosophical argument against paying a conventional one-third takeover premium.
Still, the offer of 48 euros per share including an 8 euro dividend still looks pretty meagre at 19 percent over Friday’s share price. Rothschild’s starting valuation is weak after all. Shareholders may grumble that the dividend is just paying them cash they already own, but it’s contingent on the offer proceeding, making it hard to disentangle.
Unfortunately for the minority shareholders, their hand isn’t strong and there’ll be no rival buyer. If they want more, they’re just going to have to hang tough.